Monday, 6 September 2010

Those five pledges


At the launch of his leadership bid today(though to be honest everyone has been aware that he has been campaigning for the job since before the Westminster campaign) Basil McCrea outlined his five pledges to the membership.

The first promises that, should he become leader, McCrea will not take a ministerial portfolio, instead devoting all his energies to rebuilding the UUP.I actually like this one as the task in re-building the party at this stage is probably a full-time job and I certainly would like to see Tom Elliot make the same commitment.

The second vows to make education the first choice ministry for the UUP. Bit of a no brainer this one as every party will want to say the same thing during the election campaign. The challenge will be to outline what we will do with it once we have it. Given that Basil is the education spokesperson a lack of clear direction is of concern and is something that Basil will have to address in the next few weeks.

Third Basil pledges not to form electoral pacts. A very sweeping statement which leaves no room for manoeuvre and given the long term discussions needed to address the issue of voluntary coalitions in the future very short-sighted.


His fourth pledge is a strange one. Every MLA to have a vote of confidence from the entire party every year. To what end? What will be the consequences of losing such a vote? Resignation? How will those from differing parts of the country make an assessment of the value and contribution of an MLA from another constituency? Of course one could always take a cynical view of the proposal. Should Basil win the leadership the threat of a no confidence vote would act as an incentive for MLA's to toe his line. Anyone raising their head above the parapet can be removed. And thus a dynasty was born!

Lastly he pledges to compel elected representatives to attend executive meetings. Of course, given item four above, Basil will hope that none of the MLA's would dare raise their voice against him and having them at the executive will help with control of the party. This of course is strengthened by his decision to remove the entire officer team. It is unclear at this stage if he intends to replace them and if so how. Following the party rule changes the officer team is elected by the members and to change the rules Basil would require a 2/3rds majority of the party membership.

All in all Basil has based much of his campaign on seeking to remove what he calls the "cabal". His five pledges suggest that he wants to replace the "cabal" with a cult.

Saturday, 4 September 2010

Sabbatical over

The blogging sabbatical is over and with the best intentions in the world I'll be commenting on issues that take my fancy on a regular basis.

Wednesday, 5 May 2010

That poll

Questions for Belfast Telegraph re poll results presented prior to 6th May 2010 General Election

What are the Belfast Telegraph Editorial Guidelines in relation to reporting on opinion polls?

When was the poll commissioned if it was commissioned?

What was the tendering/selection process?

Are Inform members of the British Polling Council or a similar professional body?

What are the qualifications of those from Inform who designed and carried out the poll in relation to opinion polling?

What was the editorial process for agreeing the questions to be used?

What was the editorial process to agree the profile of respondents?

Was the polling carried out on a face-to-face basis or by telephone?

In relation to the use of the information collected to provide “a snapshot of voting intentions” what is the sample size used per constituency to predict the results of the poll?

What is the expected margin of error due to sample size and the margin of error due to the length of time between the date the poll was carried out to the release of the results?

What qualifications do the directors of Inform have to make editorial comment on the results of the poll?

What was the editorial decision making process in using information from the poll?

Was the Belfast Telegraph provided with all of the information arising from the poll and then made an editorial decision on what to publish or was the information selectively provided by Inform?

Which political parties received a full breakdown of all the polling data, including that not used by the Belfast Telegraph, before its publication by the paper?

The UK Polling Report is a highly respected website that analysis political opinion polls. It is run by Anthony Wells from You Gov. In its comments of the Inform poll it states the results are “nigh on useless for predicting a winner in all but safe seats”. Would the Belfast Telegraph outline what benefit a “useless” poll is to the democratic process when published 2 days before a general election?

Thursday, 11 March 2010

Conservative/UUP relations

In a recent letter to the Newsletter it was suggested that the UUP has little influence with the Conservative Party. In fact the very opposite is true. The author of the letter has failed to take account of the very real change in Conservative Party policy where the next Government will be committed to the Union. A change brought about by the direct intervention of the UUP. Perhaps the DUP and others would prefer the semi-detached neutral commitment of a Labour Party which for so long has sought to avoid taking a stance on the issue.

The UUP has continued to work with our Conservative colleagues to create the opportunity for Northern Ireland to have the flexibility to develop our economy and attract new business. Again something neither Labour nor other local parties have committed to do.

The UUP recognises the role and function of a national party in national politics in the same way that the Conservatives recognise the role and function of a regional party in regional politics. Whether we refer to Scotland, Wales or Northern Ireland devolution has changed the relationship with national politics. We in the UUP are mature enough to recognise that and work with our colleagues in the Conservatives to make politics at all levels work.

Obviously there are those who believe that national politics are about a part-time commitment with a full-time wage and about a semi-detached relationship with the rest of the UK. Like those who represent them they will find this process hard to understand. We will be happy to outline the benefits of full engagement within the United Kingdom to Irish Nationalists and Ulster Nationalists alike.